Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Calum Macintyre's avatar

At last there is a bit of Gary critique. Although i dont necessarily think that the points in the article above are that important. I think its good that he just has a simple message about taxing the rich. He's an amazing communicator but IMO he is just the same as all the other great voices out there who keep saying 'we need to build a grassroots movement' but then they never seem to put the time in to try to understand how you actually do that. I would take what Gary is saying way more seriously if he was sharing underneath his videos concrete calls to action for people to join a meeting, sign up to attend a protest or go help mobilise others on the streets and doors around the UK to genuinely build political power. L

I saw that greenpeace UK video of him (https://www.instagram.com/reel/DHqyuv3NDpb/?igsh=d2RjdTNiN3VxdXRq) giving a speech in London - got the crowd cheering with everything he is saying and at the end his call to action was basically - 'go home and talk to your mates'. It's just not good enough IMO - these people have to understand that building movements is not just about getting millions of views on youtube. You need to understand how to create concrete pathways for people to be able to get involved in creating the change themselves and give them agency - like what Jon was saying in the citizens podcast.

To me its the same as all the outdoor athletes (and organisations) who share photos and nice information about melting glaciers and call themselves 'changemakers'. There is never a call to action, never a concrete easy way for regular people to get involved and to join a meeting and talk with others. Building a movement is learning how to do phone banking, how to doorknock and get people into a meeting, how to provide those people with a next step to help the movement grow once they come to the meeting, creating a system to collect contact details in order to follow them up, mobilising people to a protest, to write to their MP, to organise community events to build local resilience etc etc. Social media is amazing for getting in touch with millions of people but if that's the limit to their political engagement then I think it's a waste of time.

It's kinda the reason I was sharing that idea with you about the House Of The People by https://timetoassemble.org/ - because its something concrete everyone can get involved with. I would take what Gary says so much more seriously if he was using his platform and influence to help grassroots movements like that......

Expand full comment
Chris Sayer's avatar

Guess I’m a Lawrence Wong fanboy now.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts